Dear Church Leader, Don’t Hire a Discipleship Pastor

Discipleship is enjoying a resurgence in US America. While it has long thrived in other parts of the world, US Pastors have been content to ride the wave of church growth for decades. While there’s nothing wrong with growing a church, our obsession with it has distracted us from our primary calling: making disciples.

After years of repeatedly ignoring the topic, pastors are now wrestling with how to accomplish this task or admitting they’ve never been discipled and therefore have no idea where to begin. Both are healthy, honest responses.

Abundant Resources

We’ve come a long way since 1963 when Robert Coleman wrote The Master Plan of Evangelism. Coleman’s book put discipleship on the map. While other books were published before and have been since, Coleman is the rare author who got noticed, getting his resource to more than three million pastors and Christians committed to the cause.

Authors like Jerry Bridges, Ken Shigematsu, Gary Thomas, Bryan Loritts, Bill Hull, Dallas Willard, Leonard Sweet, and Pete Scazzero have produced dynamic resources that invite, challenge, and equip us to make disciples.

Organizations like The Navigators, Cru, and InterVarsity continue to equip the church by having a presence on college campuses. gathers like-minded individuals for an annual conference, and individuals like Justin Gravitt, Robbie Gallaty, and David Putman create outstanding podcasts and webinars.

Discipleship is back. 

But still, there is reason to be cautious, as churches hire discipleship pastors to lead the charge. While that might appear to be the most encouraging sign of all, seeing churches put their money where their mouth is through staffing, this hiring habit has the potential to initiate the beginning of the end of our disciple-making revival.


Hiring a discipleship pastor could signal to the church that they no longer have to worry about making disciples because they’ve delegated that task: there’s now a professional for it.

But it doesn’t have to be that way.

Here are two commitments to prevent delegating disciple-making.

Give every staff member a new title.

While you don’t have to print new business cards or nameplates, cast a vision that every staff member is a disciple-maker. In other words, tell your youth pastor she is no longer the youth pastor. Instead, she is now the Disciple-making Youth Pastor. Your Minister of Music is now the Disciple-making Minister of Music, and your Senior Pastor is now the Disciple-making Senior Pastor.

Carry this vision to your congregants. Get rid of your members, and invite them to be Disciple-making members. Remove your Small Group leaders and ask them to be Disciple-making Small Group leaders. 

But, this initiative will not gather any momentum unless you make the second commitment:

Create a church-wide disciple-making culture.

It’s crucial to shift from an activity-based mindset to a disciple-making culture. Don’t limit disciple-making to a class or activity at the church once a week. Instead, infuse every church activity, budget line, and ministry with disciple-making as the goal.

Everything should be viewed and evaluated through the following filter: How does this help us make disciples?

Admittedly, this is the hardest step. Cultures are not made by adding water and bringing it to a boil. The change you seek will not happen overnight, but you might lose your job overnight if you force the issue.

Creating culture takes time (lots and lots of time), intentionality, teammates, prayer, and patience. Let’s ruminate on this topic for a bit, and in the meantime, consider the following resources:

QUESTION (leave a comment below)

If you’re a pastor, how does this article excite or frighten you?

If you’re a church member or attendee, how do you think your pastor will respond?

I want to help you say "No" to a boring life and "Yes" to a faith that matters. Let's make a plan for your life, for your church, or both! Contact me at

6 thoughts on “Dear Church Leader, Don’t Hire a Discipleship Pastor

  1. Greg, thank you for putting your thoughts to paper. Hiring Discipleship Pastors is similar to the hiring of the pastor of evangelism by many churches in the 80’s and 90’s.
    In the Western world, we like to professionalize any responsibility that has risk or requires skin in the game. We hire others to do the things that matters most, so we can inoculate ourselves from vulnerability or pain. Our affluence may be making us lazy. It affords us much but costs us more.
    I remember talking an older church members in my first ministry about death in 1987. They told me stories of how the viewing/wake of a passed family member would happen in their living room when they were kids. When my wife’s grandfathers heath was failing they brought him to their home and cared for him until he passed. Today we have funeral homes and hospice centers. I am thankful for both. But I wonder what we have lost in the west by separating ourselves from these sacred experiences.
    I am with you. If your church wants to hire a Disciplemaking Pastor, I affirm it with one caveat. Rather than saddle your new pastor with the insurmountable work of disciplemaking for your church, make him/her the champion of this mission and the one that equips the staff and the congregation to get out there, with their sleeves rolled up and make disciple who make disciple. Be a Ephesians 4 leader that mobilizes the saints to live out the great commission. Don’t just professionalize the mission of the individual follower of Jesus. to do so cheats your people out of the sacred and the great blessings and secrets of the abundant life. To invest in others walks with Christ and share the Good News- the best news with your neighbors, friends and family.
    And I love your point to put disciplemaking in everyone’s title. I might steal that idea for our church where I am an elder.

    1. Yes, yes, and yes!!! Great thoughts and so true about the examples you shared. Thanks for taking the time.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *